Photo Journal

Adobe RGB vs. ProPhoto, Blender

Exploring Color Theory with Blender

by |

Warning: This post is for color nerds.

Moving on…

From time to time I post plots of color gamuts like the one above. Each time, I get email asking how I make them leading me to assume that the world's thirst for color nerdiness is going unquenched. I'm setting out to fix that in this post. There are several applications that produce graphics like these on demand including Apple's ColorSync Utility, ColorThink Pro, and Gamut Vision. These are all terrific applications and they all do a lot more than plot gamuts, but when I make these graphics, I do it from scratch using Blender and its Python scripting interface.

Blender is an open source 3D modeling/rendering application. Because you have to tell it explicitly what to do at every step, working with color geometry in Blender is a really good way to sharpen your understanding of the technical details. And unlike software dedicated specifically to plotting colors, Blender imposes no limitations on your creativity.

THE RGB CUBE

color cube

This is a good exercise to begin with: create a cube at the origin with sides one unit long and subdivide it a few times. Since all the points in the cube will have coordinates ranging from 0.0 to 1.0, you can assign each vertex an RGB color identical to the coordinates of its location and end up with the classic color cube. The color cube has some interesting properties: primary colors (RGB) and their complements (CMY) sit on opposite vertices. The most saturated colors are on the face of the cube with colors desaturating as you move into the cube. The line connecting the white and black points holds all the gray colors.

Relationship between the color wheel and the RGB Cube

color wheel

If you turn the cube so you are looking straight down on the white corner, you'll see the vertices of the three primary and three complementary colors arranged on a hexagon in the order of the color wheel. If you have used hue, saturation, and brightness (HSB) to specify colors and wondered why hue is specified in degrees, here's your answer. From this view you see red at 0º, and working counter-clockwise in 60º increments: yellow (60º), green (120º), cyan (180º), blue (240º), magenta (270º), and back to red (360º). These are the exact angles you'll see if you set Photoshop's color palette to HSB.

Comparing Color Gamuts in CIE XYZ Space

XYZ Gamut

Comparing color spaces in RGB doesn't work because all RGB color spaces have the same numeric values ranging from zero to one-hundred percent—you always get the same cube—but these numbers don't represent the same colors. It's another way of saying that RGB color is device dependent—a triplet of RGB numbers by itself doesn't specify a color unless you also have a profile attached to it describing the device or color space those numbers are intended for. One of the main jobs of a color profile is to provide instructions to the color management system about how to turn a set of RGB numbers into coordinates in an device-independent system like CIE XYZ space. The above graphic uses simple matrices available from Bruce Lindbloom to convert two RGB cubes into XYZ spaces using the ProPhotoRGB profile and the Adobe RGB (1998) profile. Once in XYZ space it is easy to see that the ProPhoto gamut completely contains the smaller AdobeRGB gamut. You can also see that the white points (the top right vertex in this image) are aligned because I have adapted them to D50. It's a necessary step when comparing colorspaces with different white points.

Comparing Color Gamuts in CIE Lab Space

LAB Gamut

The same two spaces as above, but converted to Lab space. Looking straight down the L axis. This is the same model as the image at the top of the page viewed from a different angle. Lab space is more appropriate for comparing color gamuts because, unlike CIE XYZ space it attempts to be perceptually uniform.

Adobe RGB gamut in xyY space

xyY Gamut

The thin, red line is where the spectral colors fall in this space. This is a view you don't often see because it's not especially useful and most software won't produce it out of the box. But it is interesting because if you move the camera above the xy plane and point it straight down with an orthographic view (no perspective), the result is a very familiar graphic:

xyY Gamut This is the most common way of quickly showing the gamut of a color space. But as you can see in the image above it, this xy chromaticity graph is a simplification of a three-dimensional solid. This has practical implications—there are colors that from this view look like they are in gamut because they fall within the triangle on the xy plane, but are not. In other words the chromaticity diagram should be used with caution.

Other strange things

LAB Tints
Blender places very few limits on your creativity. For instance, you can dismantle a model to expose its internals. The conversion from XYZ to Lab is a non-linear transformation. What starts out as simple triangles in the RGB cube connecting each primary vertex to the black and white points becomes warped in the transition to Lab space—a reflection of the non-linear nature of our color perception that is Lab space attempts to model.

Do want to try this yourself?

First you need a copy Blender and maybe some tutorials. Bruce Lindbloom's site is a treasure trove of formulas and instructions for converting between color spaces. To get you started here is my Blender file which has a simple Python script showing how to do the transformations between a few color spaces in Blender and how to assign vertex colors with Python in Blender 2.66. It also has the material to make wireframes in Blender's Cycles renderer, a trick I learned here.

11 Reader Comments

René Rebe

Awesome! Just when we happen to implement more accurate color support in our ExactScan ;-)

Light

I have always been interested in traditional RYB color wheel (ie: Coolorus, using traditional pigment and real color relationship), unfortunately I can't code that (yet). Can you provide an example for that too?

Edmund Ronald

Neat - Beautiful diagrams!

Edmund

Matt

Excellent article. You were right, my thirst for color nerdiness wasn't quenched, until now. Thank you so much, I love this stuff.

syed

very soon i wount do anything in Photoshop but blender only

Ed Cole

Excellent study material!

GetUserName

This tool could be expanded to further represent other color spaces for data analysis (color, staturation and value for example). I have personally implented this visualization and functionality in nonfree software, but having this freely available in open source would be of benefit to color scientists.

I will have to download the tool, but I do question why exterior lighting effects were applied to what is an attempt to accurately represent color space? I can only hope it was only to make some fancy pictures for this article.

Steve Taylor

This is delightful - good work.

Just a typo to note: you are using "complimentary" where you should be using "complementary".

Craig Woods

Great work! So if I'm doing color correction in RGB space, I'm stretching the R, G or B vertices of the cube. If I'm messing with the exposure, it's just the black and white vertices. And if I'm adjusting saturation, I'm shrinking or expanding the cube, right?

Gary Jordan

Hi Mark,

I was wondering if you could advise me on how I should import my renders from Blender into Photoshop.
I am totally lost as to how to colour manage these images!!! I would really appreciate any help.
My colourspace in Photoshop is Adobe RGB 1998.
Thanks a million Mark and great blog!!
Cheers
Gary

Comments are closed for this note